New York's Best Toy Stores: FAO Schwarz, LEGO, Nintendo and More
New York's big toy stores are attractions in their own right: you can dance on a giant floor piano, print your own LEGO minifigure, play the newest Nintendo games and drink Butterbeer. Best of all for planning, the biggest names sit within a few blocks of each other around Rockefeller Center.
Entry is free everywhere. The paid extras (experiences, personalised toys) add up fast, so read on for what each store offers and how to keep the visit fun for everyone.
The short answer
- Toy stores in one walk: FAO Schwarz, the LEGO Store on Fifth Avenue, Nintendo New York and American Girl are all around Rockefeller Center, between 48th and 52nd Streets.
- Little ones (3 to 7): FAO Schwarz for the floor piano, the toy soldiers and the stuffed animals.
- Builders: the LEGO Store on Fifth Avenue, for the Pick & Build Wall, the Minifigure Factory and Brick Lab.
- Gamers: Nintendo New York, to try games at the demo stations.
- Harry Potter fans: Harry Potter New York, by the Flatiron Building, for Butterbeer and the broom experience.
- A quieter shop: Mary Arnold Toys on the Upper East Side, a family toy store since 1931.
FAO Schwarz (30 Rockefeller Plaza)
New York's most famous toy store, on the plaza by the Rockefeller Center rink. Each morning, the toy soldiers hold a free Opening Ceremony on the plaza (not in bad weather), and inside you'll find the Dance-On Piano, a giant floor keyboard you play with your feet.
Most of the extras are paid experiences that make a personalised toy: adopt a baby doll (ages 6 and up), stuff a Steiff teddy, build a Build-A-Bear, personalise BRIO train carriages or style a Barbie (ages 3 and up). Most are first come, first served with no booking; the Jellycat Diner needs a reservation. Each one is priced like a big present, not a souvenir, so check the price on the store's website before kids join the queue.
The LEGO Stores (Fifth Avenue and Flatiron)
The LEGO Store Fifth Avenue (636 Fifth Ave, at Rockefeller Center) is the two-storey flagship. Kids fill a cup from the Pick & Build Wall, put together a figure at Build a Minifigure, and design and print their own torso at the Minifigure Factory. The Mosaic Maker turns a photo into a LEGO portrait (book a slot), and Brick Lab, for fans 6 and up, is a 20-minute session mixing building with digital play: booking is required, and you should arrive 15 minutes early.
The LEGO Store Flatiron District (200 Fifth Ave) has the Pick & Build Wall, Build a Minifigure and the Minifigure Factory too: handy if you're downtown near Madison Square Park. Look for the New York sets, like the yellow taxi, which make good small souvenirs.
Nintendo New York (10 Rockefeller Plaza)
On 48th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues. The draw is the demo stations, where staff help you try Nintendo Switch games, plus the Nintendo Showcase of items from the company's history and merchandise from Mario Kart, Zelda and Donkey Kong. There's a My Mario range made for young children. The store holds events around game releases and the holidays; check its page before you go. The nearest subway is 47-50 Sts-Rockefeller Center (B, D, F, M).
Harry Potter New York (935 Broadway)
On 22nd Street next to the Flatiron Building. The Butterbeer Bar serves Butterbeer in a souvenir tankard, as ice cream or bottled; the Hogwarts Broom Experience is a broomstick flight attraction with tickets sold only in the store; and you can personalise house robes, trunks and even a Hogwarts acceptance letter. Pair it with the LEGO Store Flatiron District, a few blocks away on Fifth Avenue.
More stores worth a stop
- American Girl (75 Rockefeller Plaza, on West 51st Street): two floors with a doll salon (for American Girl dolls only), a café for brunch, lunch and tea (book ahead: it fills at lunch), ear piercing by reservation, and a doll hospital.
- Disney Store Times Square (1540 Broadway): Disney, Pixar, Marvel and Star Wars toys and costumes.
- M&M'S Times Square (1600 Broadway): three floors of M&M'S, with a two-storey wall of coloured candy.
- Mary Arnold Toys (1178 Lexington Ave, at 80th Street): a neighbourhood toy, book and game shop open since 1931, an easy walk from the Met.
How to visit without a meltdown
- Agree on the budget before you go in: a set amount per child, or one thing each. Saying it on the pavement is much easier than in front of the Pick & Build Wall.
- Go when the doors open. Weekend afternoons and the weeks before Christmas are the busiest; on weekday mornings there's room to play.
- Look first, buy last. Walk the whole cluster, then go back for the favourite. It ends most "but I want that one too" debates.
- Pick what you can only get here: a printed minifigure, a personalised toy, a New York set. Most big boxes are sold at home too, and they're heavy to fly with.
- Leave the big stroller behind if you can: the stores are crowded, and FAO Schwarz and the LEGO Store have more than one floor.
- Make it part of a day: our one-day plan and rainy-day plan both stop at Rockefeller Center. In December, add the tree and the rink: see New York at Christmas with kids.
Questions
Is FAO Schwarz free to visit?
Yes, it's free to go in, and the toy soldiers' morning Opening Ceremony on the plaza is free too. The in-store experiences, like adopting a doll or personalising a teddy, are paid.
What can kids do at the LEGO Store in New York?
At the Fifth Avenue flagship: fill a cup at the Pick & Build Wall, build or print a minifigure, turn a photo into a LEGO mosaic, or book Brick Lab, a 20-minute session for ages 6 and up.
Which toy stores are near Rockefeller Center?
FAO Schwarz (30 Rockefeller Plaza), the LEGO Store (636 Fifth Ave), Nintendo New York (10 Rockefeller Plaza) and American Girl (75 Rockefeller Plaza), all within a few minutes' walk.
Where is the Harry Potter store in New York?
At 935 Broadway, on 22nd Street next to the Flatiron Building. It has a Butterbeer Bar and a broom experience with tickets sold in the store.